Cox,
W.A., R.T. Kimball, and E.L. Braun. 2007. Phylogenetic position of the
New World quail (Odontophoridae): eight nuclear loci and three
mitochondrial regions contradict morphology and the Sibley-Ahlquist
tapestry. Auk 124: 71-84.
The
evolutionary relationship between the New World quail (Odontophoridae)
and other groups of Galliformes has been an area of debate.
In
particular, the relationship between the New World quail and guineafowl
(Numidinae) has been diffi cult to resolve. We analyzed >8 kb
of DNA sequence data from 16 taxa that represent all major lineages of
Galliformes to resolve the phylogenetic position of New World quail. A
combined data set of eight nuclear loci and three mitochondrial regions
analyzed with maximum parsimony, maximum likelihood, and Bayesian
methods provide congruent and strong support for New World quail being
basal members of a phasianid clade that excludes guineafowl. By
contrast, the three mitochondrial regions exhibit modest incongruence
with each other. This is refl ected in the combined mitochondrial
analyses that weakly support the Sibley-Ahlquist topology that placed
the New World quail basal in relation to guineafowl and led to the
placement of New World quail in its own family, sister to the
Phasianidae. However, simulation-based topology tests using the
mitochondrial data were unable to reject the topology suggested by our
combined (mitochondrial and nuclear) data set. By contrast, similar
tests using our most likely topology and our combined nuclear and
mitochondrial data allow us to strongly reject the Sibley-
Ahlquist topology and a topology based on morphological data that unites Old and New World quail.